This issue of AR features a lead interview with OMA’s David Gianotten. And thorny and topical debate comes up one-sided. With the fate of the much-discussed Sirius Building in Sydney still up in the air, our question was simple: when is it appropriate to reject Heritage Council recommendations? We approached the chair of the Save Our Sirius Foundation and eminent architect Shaun Carter for one response and he was happy to oblige, but then we struck out.